Media Competencies
Media expert, Renee Hobbs, has coined 5 core competencies that students need to have to be proficient in digital and media literacy. They are as follows:
- Access: involves finding and sharing appropriate and relevant information using media texts and technology tools.
- Analyze: involves using critical thinking skills to analyze purpose, audience, and credibility (among other things) of the media that is consumed.
- Create: involves learning to be effective content creators
- Reflect: involves reflecting on how media and technology impact day to day life.
- Act: involves participating in local or global communities.
Image Source: Renee Hobbs via Twitter
Is the Medium in the Message?
The phrase "the medium is the message" was coined by famous Canadian professor, Marshall McLuhan. His theory argues that the medium in which something is presented should be regarded as more important as the message itself. This idea was heavily portrayed in the famous presidential debate between Richard Nixon and John F. Kennedy. The debate was presented to audiences through broadcasts on national television and the radio-- those who watched the debate on TV believed that Kennedy won the debate, while those who listened to the debate on the radio believed that Nixon had won. While the content was the same, the media was different, and thus it was interpreted differently.
I feel that this idea can tie in with Hobbs's third competency, Analyze, and fourth competency, Reflect. These competencies require individuals to analyze and reflect on media that is consumed; in analyzing and reflecting, people must consider not only the content that they consumed, but also the manner in which it was presented. For example, if two people were reading about the same topic, but one person got their information from a platform like Facebook and the other got their information from a platform like Twitter, their opinions could differ; Twitter limits posts to 280 characters, so the message could come across differently because of the constraints of the platform.
Classroom Applications
Why are Hobbs's competencies relevant today? Simply put, students today must be both functionally and digitally literate in order to adequately participate as a 21st century learner. In an interview printed by Society for Media Psychology & Technology, Dr. Hobbs is quoted as saying that "digital and media literacy is an expanded conceptualization of literacy". Without being competent in these 5 core areas, teachers and students alike cannot truly consider themselves fully literate. Luckily, as students and teachers strive to be lifelong learners, they can acquire these concepts over time.
As many districts are one-to-one with devices for students to use throughout the school day, I feel that acquiring these competencies should be something that can be easily integrated into instruction. For example, I feel that the majority of the ideas discussed in the five competencies go hand in hand with various Common Core Standards for both ELA and Social Studies; giving students opportunities to practice skills outlined in the various competencies, such as researching, assessing a source's credibility/validity, and creating media for others to consume is likely already happening in many classrooms. In teaching 21st century learners, teachers need to be mindful of using 21st century practices to create digitally competent individuals!

Hi Kelly! I really appreciated your perspective on which of the 5 competencies best fit with McLuhan's theory. While I said that it could probably be argued that each competency intertwines with his theory, I decided to go with "Create." After reading your thoughts on why "analyze" and "reflect" best fit within Medium is the Message, I totally agree with you as well. Dr. Hobbs' quote rings true and we cannot expect students to be digitally literate if we are not providing them with those skills in the classroom. I was working in a 1:1 district for the last two years and I felt like my students were SO far from being digitally literate. This is probably due to the fact that I hadn't yet been educated on its importance. Going forward, I will make sure to push digital literacy if I ever find myself in a classroom again.
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for your thoughtful post! I enjoyed reading it!
Great connection to the Common Core Standards. Given that Hobbs' competencies compliment these there might be more buy-in from teachers to implement them. Along those same lines, if memory serves, there is also a Common Core Standard that talks about being able to recognize the differences in how text is presented (i.e. text message different from email, etc.) which back's up Marshall McLuhan's message as well.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHi Kelly,
ReplyDeleteGreat post! I really like how you connected the Common Core Standards with the five competencies. When students are doing a persuasive or argumentative essay, they research for sources and analyze them. They look for reliable sources like articles, videos, visuals, and more with our support. It is important to give our students the opportunity to evaluate and create media. Also, helping them be responsible creators when they share with others.